Are Magic Misprints Worth Anything?

Why I love these weird cards

Miscuts and misprints are one of my favorite things about Magic. I’ve played for decades. I’ve quit six times and come back every time. And back in the late 90s and early 2000s, I collected miscuts. It wasn’t about finding a miscut dual land. It was “oh my god, look at this miscut Duress. I have two miscut Duresses.”

Magic is a collectible game, and misprints give you a different vector to collect on. Not Japanese cards, not foils, not one-of-every-card. A playset of miscut Duresses. Dark Rituals with upside-down backs. A different target, and a different level of bling for your deck.

And bling is the engine here. Look at how Magic gets collected now: showcase frames, alt arts, custom borders, Secret Lair drops. All of it is bling aimed at some niche of the fandom. But almost all of it is bling anyone can buy, printed by the hundreds or thousands (or, in Post Malone’s case, exactly once). Misprints and miscuts democratize the rare thing. They put “I have one of maybe ten of these in existence” within reach of anyone who opens a booster pack. That’s who buys them: players and collectors who want the next level of bling in their decks, something that stands out from across the table.

The short answer

Most misprints are worth a little money. A couple bucks. If you opened a random common and it’s slightly off-center, it’s probably worth what that card is normally worth. If it’s noticeably off-cut, enough that you can see a bit of the next card, it’s usually worth a little more: a couple bucks, sometimes a multiple of the normal card.

The home runs are the cards that are dramatically wrong. The ones where your first reaction is “whoa.” Whether your card is a couple-bucks card or a whoa card comes down to three things.

The three things that decide what a misprint is worth

1. The glance test. Can someone across the table tell the card is messed up? A miscut showing half the next card and a tiny printing dot on one edge are both errors, but there’s a big difference in the market for them. Dramatic beats subtle, every time.

2. The card it’s on. Take the same error on two different cards and you get two very different outcomes. Generic draft chaff with a rare error is still generic draft chaff: constrained supply, but no demand. A popular commander is another story. Krenko has been reprinted so much you can buy him for under a dollar. I was just in a misprint auction for a severely miscut Krenko, shifted down so far the cut line ran through the name. By the time I tapped out, around bid six or seven, it was at $35. On a card that’s normally a dollar. That’s what demand does. Now scale it up: a miscut foil Force of Will from the silver scroll printings in the new Secrets of Strixhaven set and you’re sitting on real money, because the error is both the value and the value multiplier: the card already has value, and the error gives it the interest, the novelty, the multiple.

3. Who wants it. Misprint collectors are a real, specific market: collectors, players, dealers, enfranchised folks who want something a little different. They trade in misprint and oddities groups, especially on Facebook. I know store owners who play entirely-miscut commander decks. And this market has grown. Back when I ran my eBay business, misprints were novelties with thin demand. Commander’s rise and bling culture changed that. There’s real demand now.

Type by type: what’s usually bulk, what’s sometimes money

• Off-center cards. One border thicker, one thinner. Worth a little more, but not often, and not much, unless the card itself is rare and in demand.
• Miscuts. The card shifted far enough that you can see the next card. These are the interesting ones. You don’t have to measure borders; you look at it and go “huh, my Plains shows part of a Forest.”
• Crimps. The factory sealer bit the card and left a ridged stamp. Small, barely-touched crimp: mildly interesting, small multiple. Big, jagged, well-pressed crimp extending into the text box: now we’re talking.
• Square corners. The corner cutter wasn’t set right, wasn’t swapped between print jobs, or had dulled, and you get partially rounded up to fully square corners. People find these in old boxes constantly. (Collectors’ Edition and International Edition cards were officially published with square corners; those are a related novelty rather than a misprint, and yes, I buy those too.)
• Splotches, ink errors, and varnish errors. Blobs, smears, missing color layers, texture differences, spotting. An ink splotch that looks like someone spilled ink on the card gets interesting. One that spreads across a connected run of cards gets very interesting.
• Albinos and missing ink. The dramatic end of ink errors: the printer runs out of one color partway through and the card comes out ghostly. Visually striking. Also fakeable, so collectors are rightly cautious here.
• Fillers. Blank cards, or cards printed with placeholder text. They pop up in the Facebook groups semi-frequently. Not worth too much, but an interesting novelty.
• Stamp errors. A newer category: the holo stamp at the bottom of the card shifted, missing, doubled, or occasionally just wrong (some of the Secrets of Strixhaven print runs shipped cards with a Star Wars holo stamp; angle it in the light and you see X-wings instead of the planeswalker symbol). A stamp that’s off by a couple millimeters needs calipers to detect: not worth much. Dramatically shifted, sitting in the text box, or missing entirely: interesting. I paid about three bucks for a Strixhaven dean missing her stamp, purely as a novelty, and I’ve seen a commander deck where every card was missing the stamp sell for a couple bucks over normal.
• Test prints, oddities, and what-the-hell-is-this. Rare, and priced card by card. If your reaction was “what IS this?”, that’s my favorite category.

For calibration: in a typical collection, you’ll mostly see off-center cards, some miscuts, some crimps, occasionally splotches and fillers, and (these days) stamp errors. Test prints and the genuinely weird stuff are rare.

The ones that usually aren’t worth much

• Slightly off-center cards. That’s most Magic cards, honestly. Printing varies.
• Faint print lines. On a bulk common, it’s still a bulk common. And older foils (Urza’s era onward) often show a line where foil sheets met; that’s expected and normal, no bonus.
• Sun-bleached cards. Not a misprint. That’s a tan. (It’s fun to sun-bleach some Dark Rituals and play them, but they’re not misprints.)
• Varnish quirks you can only see up close. If it doesn’t show at arm’s length, it doesn’t stand out at the table, and the table is where the demand comes from.

Watch out: damage wearing a costume

Some things look like factory errors and aren’t. Binder crimps. Corners trimmed with scissors. And a fun one: fake fillers, where someone takes acetone to a foil card and rubs the ink off, leaving a shiny blank. Great for making a proxy or a personal art card. Not a misprint. Part of buying these cards is knowing the difference, and I do.

Should you get a misprint graded?

Except in very, very rare circumstances (your miscut dual land, your miscut One Ring), no. Most people who buy misprints want to play them or display them in a binder, so a slab doesn’t add value the way it can in Pokémon. It doesn’t change what I’d pay. Honestly, I view a slab as an inconvenience: I can’t handle the card, I can’t inspect it myself. Save the grading fee.

So what’s yours worth?

Three ways to find out:

1. eBay sold listings. Search completed and sold listings, not asking prices. That shows you what people actually paid. Takes time, and for anything off the beaten path the comps are thin.
2. Misprint Facebook groups. Search and you’ll find several. Post a photo, front and back, multiple angles, and say what you think you have. These folks are friendly, they love the game, and they’ll tell you straight: “we see that a lot, not worth much” or “that’s rare, auction it.” Also takes time, and an auction estimate is still a guess.
3. Text me a photo. The quick option: (541) 525-0520. Send the front and the back. I’ll tell you one of three things: “that’s cool, I don’t know what it’s worth, but it’s cool,” or “I know what that’s worth, here’s what I pay,” or “it’s not worth much, and here’s how to move it if you want to.” I usually respond within a couple hours. I’m in Eugene, I’m a cash buyer, I’m local, I’m a player.

FAQ: miscut and misprint Magic cards

Are miscut cards worth more than normal cards?

Usually a little more. It depends on the severity of the miscut and how in-demand the card is. Small off-center shifts aren’t worth much. The ones worth real money are visually distinctive from across the table.

Are crimped cards worth anything?

Depends on the card and the crimp. Draft chaff common number 83, a basic Island, and the chase rare of the set give you the whole spectrum: from “nothing extra” to “a little more” to “oh, that’s fancy.” Severity matters too: a deep, obvious crimp beats a faint one.

My card’s off-center. Is that a misprint?

A little off-center? Probably not. A lot off-center? Probably. Text me a photo at (541) 525-0520 and I’ll give you my best read.

Can I still play a misprinted card?

Good question, and the answer is interesting. Tournament rules say you play a card based on the printed name (that’s why artist alters leave the name and mana cost visible). So for most misprints, ink splotches, varnish errors, off-center cards: yes, absolutely playable. Miscuts are where it gets weird. If the card is shifted so far that the name showing belongs to the next card on the sheet, the printed name is what counts. And some misprints are confusing enough to get banned outright: there’s a famous old foreign black-border misprint, German Forests printed with Plains art and a white mana symbol, where the only tell was the word “Wald” on the title line. Looks like a Plains from across the table, plays as a Forest. Banned from tournament play. I remember staring across the table at that exact green-white deck back in the Odyssey era.

What I do with them (and what I’m hunting for)

Some I keep. I’m building an all-miscut-and-misprint Fire Lord Azula commander deck: a miscut Mocking Sprite, a miscut Chaos Warp, that kind of thing. They’re novel, they’re interesting, I like them. Some I sell to collectors who want them for their decks, binders, or stores.

And one thing I especially love buying: miscut commander precons. Occasionally a whole deck comes off the line miscut, off-center, or missing holo stamps because of an alignment issue in the print run. I buy those as a single lot whenever I can. I’ve got a couple sleeved up in my cupboard right now.

So: misprints, miscuts, an old binder full of oddities, a booster pack that came out wrong, a commander deck with visibility issues. I buy singles, collections, packs, and whole decks. Here’s the full rundown of what I buy and how it works, or just text a photo to (541) 525-0520. I’d love to see what you’ve got, even if you’re just showing off.

Related

• I buy misprint Magic cards, miscuts, and oddities
• How much are my Magic cards worth?
• How to sell Magic cards without getting lowballed